7 Common Credit Score Myths You Should Stop Believing

Your credit score plays a critical role in your financial life, from getting a loan or credit card to securing favorable interest rates or even renting a home. Yet misbeliefs about how it works can mislead you into poor credit habits. Below, we debunk seven of the most common myths about credit scores. Understanding the truth can help you manage your finances smarter, avoid unnecessary mistakes, and build healthy credit over time.

The myth: Many people fear that every time they check their credit score, the score drops.

The truth: Checking your own credit score is considered a “soft inquiry” (soft pull), which does not affect your score. Only a “hard inquiry,” such as when a lender runs your report while processing a loan or credit card application, can cause a slight, temporary dip.

Myth 2: A High Income Automatically Means a High Credit Score

• The myth: Earning a lot of money means you’ll automatically have a great credit score.
• The truth: Your income or savings do not directly affect your credit score. Credit-scoring models typically ignore income. What actually matters is how you manage credit over time: whether you pay on time, how much credit you use, and how long you’ve had credit.

So yes, you could be earning well but have a weak credit score if you misuse credit, or you could have a modest income but still build strong credit by practicing responsible credit habits.

Myth 3: Carrying a Balance on Credit Cards Helps Build Credit

• The myth: Maintaining even a small balance on your credit card rather than paying it off helps improve your credit score.
• The truth: Carrying a balance does not boost your credit score. In fact, it can hurt it by increasing what’s called the credit utilization ratio, the portion of your total credit limit you’re actually using. High utilization often lowers your score.

A better approach is to pay off your balance in full each month while using a small portion of your limit regularly. This shows responsible use without adding unnecessary interest.

Myth 4: Closing Old Credit Cards Always Improves Your Score

• The myth: losing old or “unused” credit cards will boost your credit score (or make you more credit‑worthy).
• The truth: It’s often the opposite. Closing a long‑standing credit account reduces your total credit available, which raises your utilization ratio and shortens your average credit history. Both factors can hurt your credit.

Unless a card has high fees or you’re sure you don’t need it, keeping it open (and maybe using it occasionally) is often better.

Myth 5: One Missed Payment Doesn’t Matter, It’s No Big Deal

• The myth: If you miss a payment just once, it won’t significantly affect your credit, and you can fix it next month.
• The truth: Payment history is arguably the most important factor in many credit‑score models. Even a single missed or late payment (e.g., 30+ days late) can hurt your score for years.

If you often rely on memory for due dates, setting reminders or using auto‑payments can help you avoid this common pitfall.

Myth 6: Paying Off Debt Immediately Will Instantly Fix Your Credit Score

• The myth: As soon as you completely clear a loan or debt, your credit score will shoot up.
• The truth: While paying off debt correctly helps, especially by lowering balances, improvements take time because credit‑reporting and scoring systems update periodically. Also, certain negative history (like late payments or defaults) may stay on record for years, even after you’ve repaid.

So while clearing debt is excellent, it’s unrealistic to expect an overnight transformation.

Myth 7: All Credit Inquiries Are the Same, Every Inquiry Hurts

• The myth: Every time someone checks your credit report (you or a lender), it damages your credit.
• The truth: There are two types of inquiries:
  • Soft inquiries: When you check your own credit or for background/pre‑approval checks. These do not affect your score.
  • Hard inquiries: When you apply for new credit (loan, card). These can cause a small, temporary dip in your score (often a few points), but the effect fades over time.

Therefore, routine self‑checks or pre‑approval checks are safe and, in fact, helpful.

Credit scores are complex, but you don’t need to navigate them using myths. Instead, rely on facts and consistent credit habits. Checking your own score, paying on time, keeping balances low, and being patient can make a real difference over time.

At CashAmericaToday, our mission is to not only offer financial solutions but also empower you with knowledge. By understanding how credit works and debunking common myths, you’ll be in a stronger position to make smart financial decisions, improve your credit health, and build a more secure financial future.